Maybe this is a "me" thing and not a "y'all" thing. Certain fonts make for difficult reading, whilst other fonts are tacky -- perhaps through over-use*, perhaps because they are just naturally ugly (see Comic Sans).
Papyrus combines both of these aspects -- poor readability + overused oogliness -- into one godawful package.
I will back away from a product that uses this font for its body text AND NEVER LOOK BACK. I will never purchase it. I will never allow it near my other books BECAUSE I CARE ABOUT THEM.
That is all.
*This may not apply to certain fonts that preserve an utterly generic "look" (eg. Times New Roman).